People often say that raters look for certain things, but rarely say who told them. Retired VA Rating Specialist Dewayne Kimble decided claims for years, and in a video he shows the form he used and the order he worked in. He says clearly that there are hundreds of raters, that each has their own method, and that this is one rater's approach.
Where the checklist came from
Dewayne says a master trainer at a regional office gave him the form during his challenge training, and that he used it until he retired. It helped him work faster and avoid reopening a file a second time if an exam was needed.
The order he worked in
- Identity. The veteran's name, checking for name changes or two last names, and the Social Security number.
- Service dates. Making sure the branch and dates are right, especially if the veteran served in more than one branch or left and returned.
- The conditions claimed, and on what form. He looked for an intent to file and the prescribed claim form, then listed each condition.
- What kind of claim each condition is. New, presumptive, an increase or secondary. That tells the rater what evidence to look for, instead of searching the whole file.
- The evidence that matches. For example, for an Agent Orange claim he went straight to the DD-214 for service in places the VA recognizes. For a new condition, he checked the service treatment records for treatment, a diagnosis, an injury or a complaint.
- Whether an exam is needed. If a veteran submits a Disability Benefits Questionnaire that is actionable and sufficient, he says he would not schedule an exam and could grant the condition if the link to service, a current diagnosis and a medical opinion are all there.
- The effective date. He checked the intent to file and the date the claim form was received.
The claim form matters
His worked example shows why the first steps are worth the time. In it, a veteran claims two conditions. One is a new condition with a sufficient questionnaire, so it can be granted. The other is a reopened condition sent on the wrong form. Reopened claims, now handled as supplemental claims, use VA Form 20-0995, so that one is deferred with a note that the prescribed form was not received.
How it ties to the decision you receive
Dewayne says he built the rating decision from the same checklist. A rating decision opens with the veteran's name and a short service history, then states whether each condition was granted or denied, then lists the evidence, then gives the reasons. Reading yours with that structure in mind makes it easier to follow.
Why he will not answer "what do raters want"
Dewayne is firm that claim specific questions cannot be answered without looking at the file, and that nobody can speak for every rater. What he offers is the set of questions he asks veterans now: which branch did you serve in, what are you claiming and how are you claiming it.

