Retired VA Rating Specialist Dewayne Kimble made a video listing the five mistakes he saw most often when he decided claims. He says other former raters might list different ones, and that he has seen some of these mistakes made by representatives as well as by veterans. This article follows his list.
1. Not learning how VA compensation works
Dewayne starts with basics. VA disability compensation is handled by the Veterans Benefits Administration, not the Veterans Health Administration. He describes veterans who collect diagnoses and treatment notes at a VA hospital, send a box of records to the benefits side and are denied, without understanding why. A diagnosis at a VA hospital does not by itself mean service connection, because the benefits side has its own criteria.
2. Not knowing the ways to establish service connection
He teaches that there are five ways to establish service connection, and that a condition that does not connect to one of them is likely to be denied. He compares skipping this step to building furniture without the diagram. One of those ways, secondary service connection, is defined in 38 CFR 3.310 and is covered in a separate article on this site.
3. Not preparing for the compensation and pension exam
Dewayne says a veteran should know which conditions the exam is for and what the examiner will measure. His examples: for a back claim, how range of motion is measured and which ranges match which percentage; for migraines, which criteria apply at each level. He describes a mock exam in which a question was deliberately left out, so the veteran spoke up, and says that point made the difference between a 30% and a 50% rating for that condition in the example.
4. Asking for a review without knowing why
When a decision is wrong, a veteran can ask for a review. Dewayne's concern is the veteran who simply says they will do a Higher Level Review without understanding the reason. He says a veteran should be able to name what went wrong, such as the regulation they believe was not followed, or what the correct effective date should be and why. He mentions a former Army lieutenant who prepared a binder with a table of contents for her review and won it.
The VA explains both review options on its decision reviews pages, linked below.
5. Not reading the notification letter and the rating decision
The VA sends two documents together: a notification letter and a rating decision. Dewayne says to read each one fully, more than once if needed. He gives two examples. A veteran says the VA ignored some evidence, but the rating decision lists that evidence in its evidence section, so the issue was how it was weighed, not whether it was seen. And a veteran who got a proposal to reduce benefits missed the response window because they had not read the notification letter's date and deadline.
A note on representatives
He adds that a veteran remains the one responsible for the claim even when a lawyer, claims agent or service organization files it. His example: ask for a copy of everything submitted, so you know which conditions are claimed.

