5 Statements That Can Work Against You at a VA C&P Exam | KMD89 VA Claims Consulting
KMD89VA Claims Consulting
Leave No Vet Behind

Home  /  Educational articles  /  Evidence

Evidence

5 Statements That Can Work Against You at a VA C&P Exam

A compensation and pension exam is not a casual conversation. Five common phrases, and why a rater can read them differently than you meant.

Published by KMD89Nov 11, 20267 min readEducation only
Watch the video on YouTube5 Things NEVER Say at VA C&P Exam: Rater Warns Critical Mistakes

Key takeaways

  • Examiners record what you say, so how you describe good, average and worst days matters.
  • Dewayne's extras: be specific about frequency, functional limits and flare ups.
  • After an intent to file, you have 365 days to submit the claim.

The compensation and pension exam, often called the C&P exam, is where a VA examiner documents your condition. Retired VA Rating Specialist Dewayne Kimble says he has seen examiners record things veterans said in passing. In a video he lists five phrases he thinks can hurt a claim and four extras. He frames these as his opinion from years of reading exam reports.

The five phrases

  1. "I'm fine" or "I'm doing okay." Dewayne says examiners write this down, and a rater can read it as minimizing the condition. He asks the obvious question: if you are fine, why are you at the exam? He notes that a casual answer to "how are you today" has been recorded this way.
  2. "Other people have it worse than me." The exam is about your disability, not anyone else's. You are there to describe your own condition.
  3. "I can do that on good days." Examiners often focus on good days. He says to describe the good days, the average days and the worst days, not only the best.
  4. "I probably don't qualify" or "I'm not sure this counts." His view is that the examiner and the rater decide based on the evidence, so talking yourself out of a benefit does not help.
  5. "I forgot to mention this in my paperwork." He says this can raise questions about credibility or sound like a new condition added at the exam.

On the paperwork point

Dewayne explains the practical side. If you file an intent to file, you then have 365 days to submit the claim on the prescribed form. That window is why he says there is time to review a statement carefully before submitting. If something is missing, VA Form 21-4138, Statement in Support of Claim, can be used to add to a statement. Both are described on VA.gov pages linked below.

Four extras he adds

  • Be specific about frequency. How many times per week or per day something happens. He gives the example of migraines that are completely prostrating.
  • Describe functional limits. What you cannot do and why, such as climbing stairs or lying on one side.
  • Mention flare ups. Describe what happens during bad episodes. His example is neuropathy that needs the legs propped up.
  • Refer to typical bad days. Not your absolute best or absolute worst, but the realistic range.

Where this fits

Dewayne is clear that how a veteran approaches the exam is their own decision. These points come from the claims he decided. The VA explains what to expect at an exam on its own pages, linked below, and the examiner is the one who documents what happens.

Frequently asked questions

What is a C&P exam?

A compensation and pension exam, where a VA examiner documents your condition. The VA describes what to expect on its VA claim exam page.

How long do I have to submit a claim after an intent to file?

365 days, according to the VA's intent to file page and as Dewayne Kimble describes it.

Can I add information after I have filed?

Dewayne mentions VA Form 21-4138, Statement in Support of Claim, as a way to add to a statement, and says it is better to finish the statement before the exam.

Sources and further reading

This article is educational information only. KMD89 is not accredited by the VA, is not a law firm, does not file claims on anyone's behalf and does not guarantee outcomes. Rules and VA web pages change, so check the linked sources for the current version. Based on a public video by Dewayne Kimble, a retired VA Rating Specialist.

You served. Now let us educate you on how to get what you earned.

Join thousands of veterans learning the VA claims process the right way, from a retired VA Rating Specialist who's on your side.

Educational VA disability claims consulting that helps veterans pursue the rating they earned, the ethical way.

Get in touch

235 Apollo Beach Blvd #166, Apollo Beach, FL 33572
Mon to Fri, 9 AM to 4 PM EST
© 2026 KMD89 VA Claims Consulting. All rights reserved. Disclaimer · Terms · Privacy
KMD89 provides educational information only and is not accredited by the VA, nor a law firm. We do not file claims on a veteran's behalf or guarantee outcomes.